Plot thickens at Tipperary The Jessica Harrington trained Paradis De Thaix, under Mark Bolger, was the second fortunate winner of the afternoon at Tipperary today, benefiting from the final fence fall of narrow leader Vital Plot in the ‘Thank you to Alan Quinlan’ Beginners Chase The French bred son of April Night blundered badly at the previous fence and was headed by Vital Plot before that rival exited at the last. Harrington was not present for the win. Thomas Weekes